Your local brokers.
CALL US 1300 884 779

Should You Renovate or Upsize? How to Decide What Makes Sense for Your Family

Sep 16, 2021 | Lending & Approval Help

Should You Renovate or Upsize? How to Decide What Makes Sense for Your Family

Sep 16, 2021 | Lending & Approval Help

At some point, many families hit the same question: do we improve the home we have, or move to one that fits us better?

There is no single right answer. Renovating can let you stay in a location you love and adapt your home around the way your family lives now. Upsizing can solve space problems more cleanly, especially if the issue is not just the house, but the block, the layout, or the suburb itself.

The smartest decision usually comes down to three things:

  • whether your current home can realistically be made to work
  • what each option will really cost
  • how comfortably your budget can handle the next step

Because from a lending point of view, this is not just a lifestyle decision. It is also a borrowing decision, and lenders and brokers need to look at whether the loan is suitable for your circumstances and whether the repayments are manageable.

When renovating may make more sense

Renovating often makes sense when you like where you live and the home’s problems are fixable.

That might be the case if:

  • you are happy with the suburb, schools, commute and community
  • you need better use of space rather than a completely different location
  • the block and existing home give you room to extend or reconfigure
  • you want to avoid the cost and disruption of selling and buying

Renovating can also be appealing if you have built up equity in your home and may be able to use that as part of the funding strategy. Depending on your loan, that could involve refinancing, a top-up, or using available redraw if you have made extra repayments, though access to redraw depends on your loan terms.

But renovation only works well if the project actually solves the problem. Adding a room, opening up a living area, or creating a second bathroom can be worth it. Spending heavily without fixing the main reason the home no longer works usually is not.

When upsizing may be the better option

Moving to a larger home can be the better call when the limitations of your current property are harder to fix.

That may be true if:

  • the layout is fundamentally wrong for your family
  • the block size or zoning limits what you can build
  • you need more bedrooms, bathrooms or storage than a renovation can realistically deliver
  • your suburb no longer suits your lifestyle, schooling or commute
  • you want a cleaner, faster solution than living through months of building work

Upsizing can also be the more practical choice if a renovation would be so extensive that you may need to move out anyway. In that case, the difference between renovating and relocating may be smaller than it first appears.

The costs people often underestimate

This is where the decision usually becomes clearer.

If you buy another home, you need to look beyond the purchase price. Moneysmart notes that buying and selling costs can include stamp duty, conveyancing and legal fees, search fees, pest and building reports, agent fees and advertising costs.

So before deciding to upsize, ask:

  • what are we likely to sell for, realistically?
  • how much extra will we need to borrow?
  • what will the buying and selling costs add up to?
  • can we comfortably handle higher repayments if rates or household costs rise?

If you renovate, the headline builder quote is only part of the picture. You may also need to allow for design work, engineering, approvals, temporary storage, replacement furniture, and a contingency for overruns. Renovations are also disruptive, especially when children are involved, and that disruption has a real cost even if it does not appear on an invoice.

Renovating is often cheaper than moving — but not always better

A renovation can look cheaper at first because you avoid stamp duty and selling costs. That is a real advantage. But a cheaper option is not automatically the better one.

The better question is: what are you getting for the money?

If renovating for a substantial amount still leaves you with compromises — not enough land, no extra parking, awkward layout, poor storage, or the wrong location — then moving may deliver better long-term value for your family.

On the other hand, if a well-planned renovation gives you the extra space you need and lets you stay in an area you love, it can be the more practical and less disruptive financial decision overall.

Think about the finance before you choose the path

This decision gets easier when you look at the funding early rather than leaving it until after you decide.

If you are thinking about upsizing, it is worth understanding:

  • how much you may be able to borrow now
  • what your repayments could look like on a larger loan
  • whether selling first or buying first is more realistic for your cash flow
  • whether refinancing your existing loan could improve your position before you move

Moneysmart notes that if you are switching home loans, asking your current lender for a better deal first can be worthwhile, and that having at least 20% equity and a good credit score can help with negotiations.

If you are thinking about renovating, it is worth understanding:

  • how much usable equity you have
  • whether your current loan has features such as redraw that may help
  • whether a refinance, top-up or construction-style lending option may be more suitable
  • how the renovation cost affects your repayments and buffer

This matters because lenders are not just looking at what you want to do. They are assessing whether the proposed loan is suitable and affordable for your situation.

6 Questions to help you decide – renovate or upsize

If you are stuck between renovating and upsizing, these questions can help cut through the emotion:

  • Do we still love the location?
  • Can our current home realistically be changed to suit the next five to ten years?
  • What will each option cost once we include the hidden expenses?
  • Which option gives us the better day-to-day lifestyle?
  • Which option feels more manageable financially, not just possible on paper?
  • If we spend this money, will we still feel it was the right move in five years?

That last question matters. Because this is not only about creating more space. It is about choosing the path that fits your family and your finances.

The bottom line

Renovating can be a great solution when you love where you live and the home can be adapted in a cost-effective way. Upsizing can be the smarter move when your current property no longer fits your family, your suburb, or your long-term plans.

The key is to compare:

  • the full cost
  • the real lifestyle outcome, and
  • the finance impact of both options before you commit.

Not sure whether renovating or upsizing makes more sense for your budget? Talk to Horizon Financial Solutions. We can help you understand your borrowing options, the equity you may be able to access, and what each path could look like before you make a decision.

Resources used in this article:

We use AI writing tools to help research and draft some of our blog content. Everything you read here is reviewed and approved by real people before publishing.

Andrew Leak Mortgage Broker

About the Author

Andrew Leak is the founder and director of Horizon Financial Solutions, with over 23 years of finance industry experience, including 20 years as a mortgage broker. He combines extensive lending expertise with a personalised, client-focused approach to finding suitable home loan solutions.